Sunday, October 23, 2016

Blog #5: Designing Writing Assignments for Working Class Students at the College Level

October 17, 2016

Mack, Nancy. "Ethical Representations of Working-Class Lives: Multiple Genres, Voices, and Identities." (2006) Pedagogy: Critical Approaches to Teaching Literature, Language, Composition, and Culture. (6)1: 53-78.   Online.


Nancy Mack’s central contention is “that working-class students need writing assignments in which they can occupy an authoritative position . . . that is not discounted as underprepared or limited but (is) a respected, working-class-academic identity (54).”  She goes on to say that the types of papers traditionally assigned to working class students frequently discount their “experiences, histories, and ways of making knowledge,” focusing instead on topics with which they may have little experience or interest. I would suggest the way the academy creates these barriers to students who identify as working class is the same way it creates them for other students who are outside of what she calls the “competitive, elite culture.” She points out the unacknowledged stigma attached to working class students, the assumption of an inherent “deficit or liability;” the same assumptions that attach to many students of color entering major universities. These assumptions ripple out in many directions, impacats of which are to disempower, undermine, and alienate students, often resulting in their dropping out before they graduate. The point here is not to say that all of this can be attributed to how students are treated in composition courses; however, Mack cites a report showing that the skills working class students worry about the most are their writing skills, and that marginalized students, among whom are women, working class, and students of color, leave “university because of their perception that their writing is fundamentally unacceptable (56).” To combat this problem, Mack developed a theory that stresses the importance of recognizing the plural identities working class (and other marginalized) students bring with them to the writing table; for example, the struggle of students to reconcile their identities of upwardly mobile students whose use of the language of  the academy is exactly that interpreted by their friends and family as “getting too smart for the rest of us” or in some communities of color, “acting white.” Writing assignments should give students “the discursive space” to create their own academic identity that “legitimates and ethically represents their multiple identities” (60) as workers, students, and all the other identities they bring with them into the classroom. The model Mack describes to do this is a multigenre research project that focuses on either family, community, or “peer group folklore.” She particularly emphasizes the folklore project as an opportunity for students to combine direct one-on-one interviews with academic readings; the final project is presented as multiple pieces of writing from different genres. The final step is what she calls an “expository cover letter” which students use to reflect on the processes they used in creating their project because, as she concludes, “Reflections can help us to connect theory to practice (74).”  Mack’s ability to join theory to concrete classroom assignment is the value of this article and why I think it is useful to other students in terms of creating assignments. She raises issues that must be considered to teach successfully in classrooms with students from a diversity of backgrounds.

Wednesday, October 5, 2016

Cognitive Process of Writing in Practice



Blog #4

Janks, Hilary. The discipline and craft of academic writing: building writing capacity in institutions of higher education. 2012. Reading & Writing. 3(1). Art #25. http://dx.doi.org/10.4102/rw.v3i1.25

In their article, “A Cognitive Process Theory of Writing,” Flowers and Hayes introduced the idea composition was a set of distinct, hierarchical thinking processes that the writer organizers as she sets her ideas down on the page. The response to this article resulted in a major pedagogical shift in the way teaching writing was viewed. The one thing they almost all had in common was that no longer was the writing product the focus of the teaching pedagogy as much as the process used to produce that product. Writing from her experience as a participant in a two-week course on academic writing, Janks presents what can only be seen as an almost perfect case study of Flowers’ and Hayes’ theory in practice. She describes the pedagogy used in this course as a synthesis of academic writing with several techniques of creative writing, by a professor whose philosophy was that even research writing was creative writing. Janks describes the structure of the course – two weeks of classes with the weeks separated by a month in-between – and then describes in detail the exercises done and the impacts those exercises had on her writing. Sessions such as “creativity” and “pushing the boundaries”; peer groups where members critiqued each other’s work. Activities such as free writing on “I am the color of…”  “what stops you from writing…”, drawing mind-maps of students’ research and free associating on the word “before.” These go directly back to Flowers and Hayes’ four points; they are examples of how process can externally introduced and guided and how it works. That is its relevance for this course. The activities may seem far out, the methodology, “kooky,” but I it is critically important to have an open mind and understand what the theory of cognitive process really means when put into practice creatively. Its application becomes even more relevant because we have students from all different disciplines but they will all have to write research papers and do academic writing. It is our responsibility to teach them  how to do it in a way that demystifies it, makes it accessible to them, and gives them alternate tools to break through what are sometimes long-established barriers from historically bad experiences with writing. Although this may have been an unorthodox article, it was valuable article in demonstrating in a concrete way what process can mean and how we have to open our own minds to being more creative.

Monday, September 26, 2016

Creative Writing Pedagogy

Blog #3  -  September 26, 2016

Lim, Shirley Geok-lin. Lore. Practice, and Social Identity in Creative Writing Pedagogy. (2010). Pedagogy: Critical Approaches to Teaching Literature, Language, Composition, and Culture. 10(1). 79-93. http://eds.a.ebscohost.com.proxy.lib.odu.edu/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid=be3fcec4-ccdb-47a8-8d56-785c48aebf97%40sessionmgr4007&vid=1&hid=4210



In this essay, Lim raises important questions about the mission of creative writing programs, the development of creative writing pedagogy and its relationship to how creative writing workshops are actually conducted, the ongoing discussion about whether creative writing can be taught and the value of creative writing programs to innately talented students. She raises these questions in order to lay the foundation for what she considers one of the most important challenges facing the creative writing workshop today: the “absence of ‘diversity,’ particularly as a raced, culturally, communally, and marginally specific subject in the 'lore' of the workshop narrative."

She opens the essay with a definition of "lore" - the term used "to describe standard practices in writing instruction." She uses the lore discussion to raise and discuss pedagogically two of the fundamental questions facing creative writing pedagogy today: “can creative writing be taught” and "what is the mission of creative writing?"

Having raised these questions, Lim proceeds to the real heart of her article, what she calls the “conscious construction” of language to be purposely and explicitly inclusive.  She uses the metaphor of the "elephant in the creative writing classroom"; instead of being approached directly, race, culture, and ‘diversity’ are more often cloaked in the that all-important aspect of creative work, "Voice."  Voice has many different terms of expression depending on who is talking about it, ranging from the “traditional Euro-white, Anglo-British, male subject to (now) include gender and other attributes of privilege in any given context.” One possibility that Lim points to for uncloaking the elephant is the ability for creative writing classrooms to become a place for  introducing social responsibility into the model, freeing previously silenced voices, and "allow(ing) for multiple kinds of writing (and reading and talking) rather than relying upon those language activities that merely aim for 'finished' student writing."

The issues Lim discusses are of immediate interest not only to creative writing pedagogy but to all writing education pedagogy. For, as Lim quotes Judith Harris in this especially salient observation, "How can a student write as a self without first formulating a social context in which to express the personal?"  Inside the classroom, the responsibility for creating the conditions that allow that social context to develop rests entirely with the professor. It must be understood as an integral aspect of the pedagogy of teaching the course if we expect our students to learn what we have to teach them. Uur ability to successfully create the conditions for that context is a prerequesite for our students’ ability to succeed.  We nust begin from the premise that "writing is a collective act, an act that builds on the attempts of other writers to transform silence."


Making Education More Accessible to Trans Students

Blog #2 

September 19, 2016

Making Higher Education More Accessible to Trans Students

Spade, Dean. Some Very Basic Tips for Making Higher Education More Accessible to Trans Students and Rethinking How We Talk about Gendered Bodies. (2011). Radical Teacher.  92, 57-62. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/463370


As transgender students become more visible in classrooms, educators have been faced with a range of new challenges. Access to facilities such as locker rooms and bathrooms have received the most outside attention, but pedagogical questions also arise for instructors who strive to make their total learning environment as positive as possible. This includes assuring accessibility to trans students by “avoiding unintentional exclusionary practices” and remedying obstacles to trans students' classroom participation. As Spade predicted in 2011, the need to address these issues has grown and the "tips" he offers for making it easier for trans gender and other gender nonconforming students to feel more comfortable and included are more relevant today than ever.

Names, pronouns, gender identity  
 
Much of the awkwardness instructors and students feel when interacting with transgender and gender nonconforming students comes from not always knowing what pronoun to use and what name to call the student (in transgender students, it is often different from her/his birth name).  Spade suggests instead of calling the roll, a sign-in sheet be passed around on which students can say how they self-identify and by what name they want to be addressed. He gives several tips for specific circumstances, but the most importance is to set a tone of respect in the classroom.  He emphasizes the need to make the classroom a safe space for students, and I believe this is of particular importance in a writing class at whatever level, because students will always be encouraged to write in their most authentic voice, and this will never happen if they do not feel safe enough to do so.

He goes on, however, to offer additional suggestions which I think are equally important for creating an environment in which students will be encouraged to write most freely. Educating oneself about trans history, trans experience, trans resistance and understanding what gender nonconforming means will allow the professor to bring more authenticity herself to how she runs the class. This then leads into the next step of including trans issues and gender nonconforming literature on the syllabus, making sure that the full spectrum of experience is included, not just that of wealthy white trans individuals.  This also involves thinking and talking about gender norms and what they mean, how do they influence what we read and how we write, and what we write about?

Talking about gendered body parts

In the second part of the article, Spade focuses on the language used to describe and talk about the parts of the body that are gendered, that is, reproductive and sex organs.  He proposes that the only way to ultimately eliminate the historical gender bias that attaches to our biologically determined body parts is to dismantle the connection between gender and part. In practice this would mean saying, for example, "people who ejaculate" and "people who menstruate" and so on. Without commenting on the many issues this proposal raises on all different philosophical, political,  sociological, and other fronts, it is enough to point out that simply from a rhetorical perspective this would be a  major  disruption of the language, written and spoken, in a profound way with tremendous implications for English pedagogy.  There is no evidence that it would improve the English language in any way, in fact a strong argument can probably be made for it having a negative effect, but that would be beside the point. The crux of the argument is whether it would be worth it terms of the greater inclusionary value of language; a classically whether the ends justifies the means argument. Spade does not address this aspect and nor will I, but I think it is a fair point to raise nonetheless when an article appears in a journal read by educators. 

I think this article has great value for students of English pedagogy, although I suspect most would not give it a second glance were they to see it in a table of contents. It is also, of course, a "hot button" issue which many people would prefer not to acknowledge at all, even in the context of higher education, especially if that education is in any way supported by state funding.  Nonetheless, it raises issues about situations in which educators are increasingly going to find themselves and an ostrich-like attitude is not going to be possible. Thought-provoking articles are important not only for those entering the field, but for those who are entrenched in it; and the more provocative sometimes, the better. I think that the first part of the essay is excellent and should be read and considered by every student who takes the Eng 664 course and anyone who teaches any of the composition courses.  I think the second part of the essay is valuable because, in its wonderful extremity, it highlights in a way that it might not be possible otherwise, just how gendered our language is; how that genderization (if you'll allow me) which is so institutionalized and ingrained in our vernacular, has real political and sociological implications for the way we perceive men and women differently regardless of how unconscious we are of doing so; and how uncomfortable it should - though I suspect it won't and will be mostly dismissed as ridiculous - make us feel if we really think about it. The author enumerates in the very first paragraph of the section all the ways the presence of a uterus, for example, shades the way women are just inherently perceived.

Although I'm very certain the author did not it intend it in this way, when reading this section I could not help but think of Jonathan Swift's "A Modest Proposal et al.  This article fits very well in my continuing consideration of the pedagogy of race, “multiculturalism” and cultural values in the writing classroom.